If you’re in a hurry to figure out what best baby bottle for breastfed babies, we recommend the Comotomo Baby Bottle.
We know that bottle feeding is supposed to suck — for the baby drinking from it, not you! With so many bottles on the market claiming to be the best, most efficient, and safest for your baby, it’s hard to find which ones actually deliver on their promises.
That’s where we come in. We picked the best bottles for breastfed babies this year, the ones that actually make you and your baby’s life much easier.
Before we get into baby bottles, though, let’s answer a few basic questions about breastfeeding.
When Should You Introduce a Baby Bottle to Your Baby?
According to information on the CDC’s website. infants should be exclusively breastfed for their first six months of life. After six months, you should continue to breastfeed them while feeding them soft foods and other meals for one year or longer. Babies should be breastfed while eating complementary foods up to two years of age.
You might not be able to physically provide your breast for your child at all times during that time. You may be traveling, sick, or just too busy to properly breastfeed your child, so you’ll need to get a bottle.
However, the mechanics of breastfeeding and bottle feeding vary in important ways.
During breastfeeding, a baby uses their tongue and jaws together. The baby cups their tongue under the areola and presses it up against its palate, which flattens and lengthens the nipple.
The baby then lowers the back of their tongue to make way for the milk to stream down from the nipple to the throat. Your baby will swallow and breathe, the lips held tightly around the breast to form an airtight seal. In short, your baby has to suckle hard to drink from a breast.
This seal isn’t the same for most baby bottles. The milk drips out from the nipple — which you’ll notice if you turn a full bottle upside-down. To prevent choking, the baby lifts the tongue as a barricade against the flow of milk. The baby doesn’t have to use their jaws at all. Instead, they simply purse their lips around the nipple and let their milk come to them how they want.
The difference in breastfeeding mechanics is why some babies get “nipple confused” when switching from breastfeeding to bottles. That’s why it’s important to find a best baby bottle that mimics the mechanics of breastfeeding after the baby has had experience with breastfeeding’s mechanics.
You could introduce a bottle at any time to a baby — as long as breastfeeding has been established and made a proper routine in your and the baby’s life. Le Leche League recommends making the switch to the bottle after nipple-feeding consistently for about four weeks.
Types of Baby Bottles
The types of baby bottles, according to WebMD, include:
The good thing about plastic bottles is that they’re lightweight, affordable, and strong. Your baby could fling their bottle at a wall and the plastic will hold up.
However, plastic typically doesn’t last as long as glass. Plastic is also prone to melting or augmentation when putting in the dishwasher or boiled for sanitation. Depending on the bottle you use, the plastic could contain bisphenol A (BPA), which potentially hinders brain and behavioral growth in children.
So yeah, if you buy a plastic baby bottle, make sure it’s BPA free — and never microwave plastic!
Glass will never contain BPA, so you’re good on that front. It also lasts forever, and you can boil them to ensure deep sanitation.
However, glass is heavier than plastic, so your baby won’t be able to support their bottle on their own. Glass also shatters when dropped, which would definitely be a possibility when handling children.
The bottle themselves aren’t disposable — they’re typically made out of reusable plastic. It’s the sterilized liner that’s disposable in these bottles.
These bottles would be best for traveling, as you don’t have to worry about making sure to go home and wash your liner before feeding your baby.
However, disposing of such liners takes a toll on the environment. Besides, you’ll have to keep buying liners for each use, which can quickly accumulate costs.
Silicone baby bottles have become a new phenomenon that, honestly, makes a lot of sense for parents. It is moldable and stretchy, easy to clean, and can withstand strong temperatures.
The only bad thing about silicone is that it can be more expensive than even glass and disposable bottles. Still, we think silicone bottles are gaining popularity for a reason.
No matter what bottle you decide to get, a bottle is nothing without its teat (unless you have a prodigy child who can drink from the bottle like a cup, then congrats!). The teat/nipple of the bottle can determine how well your baby switches from breastfeeding to bottle feeding.
What If Your Baby is Still Refusing the Bottle?
This issue can be frustrating for mothers who simply want to feed their fussy child, especially since it might be hard to determine why the child refuses the bottle.
We found this YouTube video from Lauren Jane Hampshire perfectly explains how to get a finicky baby to take up bottle feeding. Here are the tips Lauren learned after getting her own stubborn baby to bottle feed.
Find the Right Baby Bottle
Silicone bottles, for example, allow your child to squish the material like a breast, making the transition from breast to bottle much more understandable for your child.
The teat determines the flow of milk your child receives. If your child is used to the mechanics of breastfeeding, they’ll enjoy a bottle that mimics such mechanics much better than a foreign one. Do your research on the bottle specifications and check out the physics of milk flow.
Start with Breast Milk
Don’t go straight from breastfeeding to formula using a bottle. That will be too strong of a change for some babies to handle. Since your baby is used to the taste of your breast milk, they’ll be able to figure out bottle feeding much faster if you use that.
When you find the best baby bottle you think your baby will take a liking to, pump some milk to use for the initial bottle feeding sessions.
Don’t Try to Bottle Feed When the Baby is Over Hungry
This sounds counterintuitive. When the baby is hungry, they should be more likely to bottle feed since they have no choice but to drink from the bottle to satiate their hunger.
But think about it: the baby is already cranky from their hunger. If the baby doesn’t know why you’re sticking a plastic nipple in their mouth, rather than your familiar breast, they’ll just get more frustrated since they’re not getting fed.
Lauren recommends waiting until the baby is calm and relaxed to introduce the baby bottle to them. Perhaps warm up the teat so it has the familiar temperature to them too.
Don’t Try It When the Baby is Over Tired
As with over hunger, the same goes for when your baby is tired. They’ll just want to sleep, so don’t try to make them learn something new. Introduce the bottle to your baby around lunchtime, after your baby had their first meal of the day but they’re still rested from the night before.
Recruit the Help of Family and Friends
Your baby is smart. They know that even if you try to make your husband feed, the baby knows you’ll be close by, so they’ll just start crying for you. If you can do so, give your baby to a parent or parent-in-law to help the baby get used to breastfeeding. The new environment with a relative will force the baby to take up bottle feeding.
There are more tips in the video. We recommend checking it out.
Now, without further ado, here are the best baby bottles we found to help feed breastfed babies.
Best Bottles for Breastfeeding:
Well, this is one of the first bottles to have been made from silicone and designed to mimic the feel and mechanics of breastfeeding.
Due to it is made from silicone, when filled with warm milk, the flexible material can be manipulated by the baby’s hands, taking on the feel of a breast.
The teat has a wide base that allows your baby to latch on rather than suckle. The nipple also has anti-colic air flow vents so that air goes in but only milk comes out. The wide base also makes the bottle easy to clean.
Every part of the bottle is made with safe materials. You don’t have to worry about your baby getting BPA, PVC, or phthalate in their system.
Comotomo has four different nipple flows to accommodate kids of various ages. There’s a slow-flow one for kids aged zero to three years old, a medium flow one for kids three months and older, and a fast flow and a variable flow nipple for kids six months and older.
This bottle is also leak-free, which means you don’t have to worry about milk spilling during the feeding process. The bottle is also microwave, boiling water, and dishwasher safe. All in all, the Comotomo sets the standard for what baby bottles should be like.
- The bottle is made from silicone, so it’s not only easy to clean but allows your baby to manipulate it like a breast.
- Wide bottle teat allows your baby to latch on and suck as if on a breast.
- Anti-colic and leak-proof bottle.
- Made from safe materials.
- Microwave, boiling water, and dishwasher safe.
- Easy to clean and sanitize.
- Bottle collapses for easy storage.
- Can’t open the bottle when your hands are wet, because it gets too slick.
- The silicone would grip the inside of carrying bags and make for fussy handling.
This baby bottle gets its “closer to nature” name because it’s shaped like a breast, facilitating the transition from breast to bottle feeding.
It can be held in three ways to help the baby feed:
- Cradled in the palm of your hand,
- Gripped like a traditional wide neck bottle, or
- From the base.
Different grips make sure you’re not holding your hand at an awkward position during feeding, as your child might take longer to feed.
The Closer to Nature nipple includes an anti-colic valve that reduces detrimental air flow that contributes to an infant’s gastrointestinal discomfort. This nipple makes sure that your child ingests milk, not air.
It is also has three different nipples with varying flow rates to accommodate differently aged babies. There are slow flow, medium flow, and fast flow nipples for zero to three-month old’s, three to six months old’s, and children aged six months and over, respectively.
This Tommee Tippee bottle is BPA free to ensure your child’s safety. With an easily cleaned bottle with an award-winning nipple design, there’s no wonder this bottle has had such high praises from parents who use it.
- Teat is shaped like a breast so the child latches quicker.
- Flexible nipple that mimics a breast.
- Bottle includes three different holding positions so feeders are comfortable.
- This bottle is made from safe materials.
- Easy to clean design.
- Sometimes leaks.
- The nipple can invert when feeding, which becomes annoying to correct.
Next, we have this bottle from MAM.
It is designed for babies who are used to breastfeeding. The SkinSoft nipple copies the look and feel of breastfeeding. The bottle’s nipple also has important ventilation holes guarantee your child does not ingest air.
The MAM’s baby bottle will be excellent for mothers who want to switch between breastfeeding and bottle feeding without confusing your child. The nipples are realistic in shape and performance, and your child won’t know the difference. Even if dad has to take over a feeding session, the child will feed as if from mom.
Babies are unlikely to reject the MAM baby bottle, so you don’t have to worry about nipple rejection. The feeding mechanism guarantees that the child doesn’t spit-up, get gassy, or need a burping after each feeding.
What makes this bottle stand out from the rest is that it opens from both the top and the bottom, making for an incredibly easy cleaning experience. None of the other bottles on this list open from the bottom.
With a highly-tested bottle that accounts the child’s and mother’s needs, there’s no way we couldn’t include the MAM baby bottle for breastfed babies on this list.
- Anti-colic bottle design.
- Removable top and bottle that allows for easy clean.
- High acceptance rate for parents who fear nipple confusion.
- All materials in the bottle are safe and non-toxic.
- Bottle markings help you measure how much you’re feeding your child.
- You have to screw on all the pieces of this bottle correctly, otherwise it will leak milk.
- The bottle may come out of the package with defaults. Be sure to test the bottle for leaks by filling it with water and shaking it around a bit.
This baby bottle from Simply Natural mimics the feel of breastfeeding, allowing you and your child to continue to bond even as you feed them from a bottle.
The nipple works, feels, and moves like moms. Unlike mom’s, though, the Simply Natural nipples come in two flows: one slow, containing around three nipple holes, and one fast, containing around nine nipple holes. The different speeds mean you can continue to use the same bottle as your child grows older.
If you get the gift set, you’ll get both a large and small bottle and nipples of different flow rates. You’ll also get pacifiers to keep your child occupied when not feeding. The pacifiers are 100 percent silicone and made to induce proper oral development.
Though the bottle is made from plastic, it’s as stiff and clear as glass. This means that you can always spot when the bottle needs to be cleaned. The bottle is so sturdy, it will handle boiling or dishwasher sanitization.
Every part of the Simply Natural baby feeding set will be BPA free. You won’t have to worry about toxic chemicals entering your baby’s system.
Overall, we found the design of this gift set useful for getting finicky babies to eat. Especially when they’re just coming off of breastfeeding, the NUK Simply Natural baby bottles will be a quick way to reduce nipple confusion and let your baby start bottle feeding.
- Bottle mimics breastfeeding.
- Comes with different flow rates to accommodate child development.
- BPA free parts.
- Sturdy bottle will withstand drops.
- Gift set comes with pacifiers.
- Sometimes warps when you boil the plastic. Keep an eye out during the process and don’t leave the bottle in hot water for too long.
- Caps may be difficult to get off.
Best Bottles for Colic:
Dr. Brown’s bottle featuring to reduce colic. The anti-colic internal vent stops your child from ingesting air bubbles that lead to gastrointestinal discomfort. The bottle also eliminates the vacuum effect that helps reduce spit-up, gas, and burping. The anti-colic bottle also prevents nipple collapse or the buildup of fluid in the baby’s ear.
The slow-flow nipple allows your child to feed themselves at a healthy pace. The silicone nipple mimics the mechanics of breastfeeding that allows maximum safety and comfort for your child.
As you wean your child off breastfeeding, you want your bottle to fit most feeding pumps. You can pump directly into Dr. Brown’s bottle to save time and clean-up during the pumping process.
We know that you want your child to get the most vitamins and nutrients during breastfeeding. You don’t want to lose nutrition during the bottle-feeding process. Luckily, a university study measured the nutrient levels of breastmilk in different baby bottles. They found that Dr. Brown’s fully-vented bottles helped preserve vitamins C, A, and E along with important lipids.
The vent system reduces milk oxidation, or air getting into the milk and making it go stale. With Dr. Brown’s bottle, babies not only get the most nutrients from milk but a full night’s sleep due to reduced colic symptoms.
- Clinically proven anti-colic nipple.
- Bottle fits most breast pumps.
- Dr. Brown’s bottle prevents milk oxidation, so your baby gets the most nutrients during bottle feeding.
- Slow-flow nipple paces the feeding process.
- Bottle leaks sometimes.
- Hard to wash and sanitize.
Mothers are the founders of the Lansinoh. This bottle’s design helps reduce nipple confusion and allows your baby to start bottle feeding more naturally. The NaturalWave Nipple has been tested and shown to reduce nipple confusion and mimic the same natural feeding actions they learned while breastfeeding.
Thanks to its anti-colic design, it can prevent the baby from ingesting air, only milk. The ventilation system makes air go to the back of the bottle and not where the nipple is, so the baby is less likely to burp or spit up their meal.
Do you know that the NaturalWave nipple is soft silicone type and this technology has based more than 50 years of breastfeeding research? The nipple is soft, flexible, and has a matte surface to enable the baby to get a secure latch and seal. The short nipple also prevents the baby from gagging while breastfeeding.
The bottle consists of three pieces: the plastic bottle, the nipple, and the outer seal. All three come apart to make bottle cleaning easier. All parts are BPA to ensure your baby is safe.
- Tested anti-colic design makes sure your child sucks in only milk, never air.
- NaturalWave bottle design encourages natural oral development.
- Bottle and nipple help your baby learn to latch.
- NaturalWave nipple made from 100 percent silicone.
- All parts of the bottle are BPA free.
- Helps feed finicky babies or babies who have nipple confusion.
- Leaks sometimes occur while using this bottle.
- Difficult to clean.
With a well-loved bottle from a trusted company, we were sure to include this Philips Avent baby bottle on this list.
Philips Avent baby bottle approved to reduce colic symptoms and aid infant digestion. The bottle’s Airflex venting system keeps air away from where the baby is suckling, so the bottle not only avoids the harmful vacuum effect but prevents your child from sucking in air.
As your child feeds, the valve integrated into the nipple flexes naturally to prevent tummy troubles causing gas, spit-ups, and burping. Even if your little one is a fussy eater, they’ll be able to eat from the Philips Avent baby bottle.
It comes apart to expose its four parts: the bottle, the nipple, the locking thread, and the cap. Each part is easy to wash and sanitize to guarantee maximum safety for your child. And let’s not forget — all parts of this anti-colic bottle are BPA free.
It also includes marking on the side to allow you to measure how much your child is feeding. If you’re worried about over- or under-feeding, these markers will ease your mind.
- Airflex ventilation system prevents your child from ingesting air.
- Bottle design reduces colic symptoms.
- Easy washing.
- All parts of the bottle are BPA free.
- Bottle markings on the side allow you to measure how much your child is eating.
- Nipples incompatible between bottle sizes.
- Milk may come out faster than expected in bottles — slow-flow isn’t very slow.
You saw a lot of baby bottles on this list, but we have a clear favorite — the Comotomo Baby Bottle.
The Comotomo vastly impressed us with its thick silicone bottle lining. No other bottle had silicone lining on this list. With silicone being easier to clean and harder to break or melt, we didn’t understand why other bottle companies weren’t getting on board.
Besides, the baby can manipulate the bottle and squish it like a breast. The wide base and firm nipple also allow the baby to latch on and suckle as they would on a breast.
Comotomo is made of safe materials. While all the other bottles at least say they’re BPA free, it makes a point to say it’s free from all toxic materials, including PVC and phthalates. The other bottles weren’t so upfront about their safety.
Also, Comotomo is easy to clean. You could throw it in the microwave to heat up the milk, put in the dishwasher for maximum cleanliness, or throw it in some boiling water for the best sanitation. You can do this with the thin plastic Dr. Brown’s or Lansinoh bottles.
With such functionality at an affordable price, it’s no surprise we chose the Comotomo Baby Bottle as the best baby bottle for breastfed babies.
Thanks for checking out this article, and we hope your baby enjoys their new favorite bottle!