If you are in a hurry to figure out what’s the best pacifiers, I recommend the MAM Glow in the Dark Pacifier.
Newborns come into the world with a suck reflex. As a consequence, babies might start to suck on one of their fingers. Alternatively, a pacifier can satisfy this need and will be much easier to remove once they get bigger.
The biggest reason to get your little one a pacifier is that it offers comfort. And when your child is relaxed, us parents can relax as well.
Here is our list for the best pacifiers of this year:
Types of Pacifiers
Several brands have created a range of pacifiers, so there are lots of different types available.
It’s All About the Nipple
There are two nipple types: orthodontic and non-orthodontic. Orthodontic nipples try to replicate a real nipple and often have a flatter surface, while the non-orthodontic are more shaped like a bulb.
A classic pacifier has three parts: the nipple, the guard (or shield) and the ring. While the nipple is the part that goes into the baby’s mouth, the guard is on the outside of the mouth, ensuring the whole thing can’t be swallowed. You’ll often see holes here to improve airflow and avoid irritation on the child’s skin. The ring is a helpful element for parents to take and hold the binky easily.
Nowadays, pacifiers mostly consist of the same parts, but most manufacturers have slightly changed the way they look.
You’ll see in the shops that you have two choices: a multi-piece paci or one that is made of only one piece. The advantage of a one-piece binky is that it doesn’t have any cracks and crevices where bacteria can pile up unperceived. However, if your little one is only soothed by a multi-piece pacifier, buy it! Just replace it a bit more often.
Pimp That Paci
Some of the best pacifiers are available with sweet or showy extra features such as:
- Stuffed animals.
- Novelty designs (e.g., with big teeth or a mustache).
- Glow in the dark.
Are Pacifiers Good for Babies?
It’s every parent’s choice whether or not to utilize a pacifier. In my opinion, they’re a helpful tool for both parents and children!
Apart from soothing a baby that’s upset, they can also help with reducing pain. Binkies are attachment objects, proven to ease separation from the mother—whether you’re returning to work or simply need to take a shower.
On the other hand, pacifiers are feared to cause a child’s first teeth to grow crooked. Luckily, this can be bypassed easily by taking the binky away before the ages of two to three years old.
It’s also thought that pacifier-use decreases breastfeeding due to nipple confusion. That’s because mom’s nipple and a paci’s nipple both require a different way of suction. Therefore, it’s advised to wait one month before giving your newborn a paci. By then, your child should already be used to breastfeeding.
Try to avoid excessive use. When used too often, there could be an increase in middle ear infections, so it’s best to limit paci-time.
Pulling the Plug
Most kids stop by themselves, but if they don’t, it can be difficult. With my older child, I had to make it a positive experience by calling on “the pacifier fairy”. My advice is not to go cold turkey but reduce the use bit by bit. And as with everything—be consistent!
To Paci or Not to Paci?
Offering your child a pacifier is always your choice. The advantages are impressive, and most of the cons can be avoided. It may be one of the best ways to comfort your baby and give everyone else some quiet time. If you decide it’s right for you and your little one, it’s time to start shopping.
How to Choose the Best Pacifiers for Babies?
Like with most things, the final decision will not be up to you but your little one. It will probably turn into a process of trial and error, but there are so many products available that you’re bound to find the perfect one.
With six years of parenting experience and testing and researching lots of baby products, I have some advice to share with you. Here’s what to look for when shopping for the best pacifiers.
Double Saves Trouble
Babies are small, and their pacifiers are even smaller. It’s as if they instantly disappear when they fall. Even if you do find it somewhere behind the sofa or under the car seat, you’ll probably find some hair and lint attached. Because no matter how clean you are, the nipple’s material attracts dust and hair.
So my advice is to always have spares.
You’ll not only need them in case of loss. On the package of the binky you buy, it’s specified how often you should change it. This is usually around two months.
Always check the paci before you give it to your little one. If it’s a multi-piece one, make sure the parts do not come apart to avoid asphyxiation.
With pacifiers, size does matter. Again, also out of safety reasons, but a nipple which is too small will not soothe your baby. One that is too big could even form a choking hazard, so take care.
There are three general size groups:
- Small: Under six months.
- Medium: Between six and 18 months.
- Large: Over 18 months.
The sizes may differ per brand. It will be indicated on the box which age the pacifier inside is suited for.
The best kind of nipple is one that looks like a natural nipple, as this will help your little one to get used to the paci much faster and easier.
Pacifiers can be made out of different materials, including:
- Silicone: Robust material and easy to clean. This material is used the most often.
- Latex: Softer material so it might be possible that a baby accidentally bites off a small piece. Make sure your little one doesn’t have a latex allergy and use other materials if needed.
- Rubber: Which is elastic latex. This material isn’t always odorless.
Want to learn more skills for soothing your little one with pacifiers? Here we found a video to show you what you can do with a pacifier:
The Best Pacifiers Reviews
If you’ve checked the nearest supermarket or baby store already, you know how overwhelming it can be to see so many brands, shapes, and colors. I’ve reviewed the best pacifiers on the market below, to help you narrow it down.
1. MAM Glow in the Dark Pacifier – Best Glow in the Dark Pacifier
The MAM glow in the dark pacifier is a great night time paci with its plump glow in the dark button. There is no ring, so not all clips will be compatible. MAM has created one which perfectly fits around the button, but this has to be purchased separately.
The glowing button is a great feature when your baby tends to lose its binky during the night. Not only does the glow help your little one to find it again, but you can also locate it without switching the light on and disturbing your child even more.
For a strong light that lasts all night, charge the pacifier next to a lamp. Avoid putting it in direct sunlight as that might weaken the nipple. Some infants can get disrupted if the glow is too bright. If that’s the case with your little one, charge it a bit less.
This paci has been equipped with an orthodontic silicone nipple. Mimicking a natural nipple, MAM has made it symmetrical as well. It makes it easy for your baby to use either way if you can handle the cute designs being upside down from time to time.
There are large air holes on the curved shield of this MAM pacifier. Because of this shape, less of the guard is resting on your little one’s face. This avoids saliva getting stuck under it and causing a rash and irritation in that spot.
A downside to this binky is that it’s a multi-piece one. MAM does include a sterilization box in the package, making it easy to sterilize the pacifiers in the microwave in just 3 minutes.
- Glow in the dark makes it easy to find.
- Symmetrical nipple.
- Curved shield avoids irritation.
- Multiple pieces, so challenging to clean.
2. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier – Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby
The Philips Soothie is a one-piece cylindrical silicone binky, which is the perfect one to start with if you want your infant to try and use a pacifier.
The paci’s simple design makes it very easy to use and handle for your little one, without offering any distractions. The Philips Soothie is constructed with a tab instead of a ring. With this tab, parents can grab the binky, but for babies, it’s difficult. This reduces the times of it accidentally being pulled out.
A downside to the tab is that you will have to be creative to put on a clip somewhere. If not, be ready to run after this pacifier every time it falls, as it tends to bounce when it touches the floor.
Some advice I can give you is to have a little extra supply of these pacifiers. Luckily, the Philips Soothie is affordably priced so you won’t have to spend a fortune on your stock.
- Simple design.
- Used by medical professionals.
- Not suited for standard clips.
3. WubbaNub Infant Pacifier – Best Combo Pacifier
This pacifier is a real conversation starter. A lot of heads will turn when others see your little one holding the WubbaNub. The combination of a cute plush animal and a silicone paci will soothe your baby twice as much.
The combo is less affordable than average, but you do get two products in return. If your little one tends to lose their pacifier often, you’ll have fewer worries with the WubbaNub. With the little stuffed animal attached, it doesn’t tend to bounce far if dropped and the bigger size helps it to be found easily. This means you won’t have to put much money towards spare ones.
With the plush attached, your baby should be able to handle and hold the paci more independently. While sucking on the nipple, the animal can be held and helps to keep the binky in its place. Only filled with stuffing, the WubbaNub is light enough to be placed in the crib. It will also be easier to find than a pacifier on its own.
The most significant disadvantage of this pacifier is that the combo can not be detached. In terms of cleaning, this will cost you a bit of extra time. The paci can be placed in boiling water, and the stuffed plush is washing machine friendly. My advice here is to make sure to have some spares because it will take a while for the little animal to dry.
- Two in one.
- Doesn’t easily get lost.
- Easy to handle.
- Not detachable.
- Priced on the higher end of the range.
4. Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT All-in-One Pacifier and Teether – Best Pacifier for Toddler
The Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT is more than just a pacifier. It has a seamless one-piece and stylish design and is available in many cute and neutral colors.
Apart from being a non-orthodontic silicone pacifier, the Cutie PAT can also serve as a teething toy. The manufacturer came up with a clever combo-design where you can pop in the nipple with a gentle push to make this a teether as well. This makes this one of the best pacifiers for toddlers.
An inconvenience is that it might turn out to be confusing for your baby to know where and when it’s allowed to bite. Make sure to change to Stage 2 once those little teeth start to break through and always give the nipple an extra check before you offer it to your child.
Another minus is that parents have reported the binky to attract slightly more lint and hair when it drops on the floor. If you are a pet owner, this is something to take into consideration. Luckily, the Cutie PAT binky is dishwasher-friendly, so it’s easily cleaned when necessary.
- Cute colors and stylish design.
- Can also be used as a teether.
- Reported to attract more lint.
5. Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier – Best Pacifier for Newborn
The Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci pacifier is made out of one solid silicone piece. A handle is attached to the butterfly-shaped shield which makes it easy to attach a clip. The form of the guard follows the curves of your infant’s face making sure to reduce irritation.
The HappyPaci newborn pacifier counts on being easy to introduce because of its familiar, non-orthodontic nipple shape. Formed exactly like the teats on Dr. Brown’s bottles, the transition between shouldn’t be a problem if you’re using both products.
The plain design of the binky doesn’t make it the most stylish one. Also, if you’re planning to give it as a gift, the packaging isn’t the most attractive so it may not be suitable. However, this reflects on the economical price, which is great if you’re on a tight budget. The lack of many stylish elements also makes it a lightweight-binky, perfect for newborns to hold inside their mouth.
As there is no maximum age limit indicated, the advantage of being light is at the same time one of the paci’s downsides. For bigger infants, it might not be heavy enough.
- Easy to attach clip.
- Same nipple as Dr. Brown’s bottles.
- Easy to clean and dishwasher-friendly
- Lightweight—not heavy enough for bigger babies.
6. Nookums Paci-Plushies Buddies Pacifier and Holder – Best Pacifier Accessory
If you’re looking for a pacifier with a lot of flexibility, Nookums Paci-Plushies are the best option for you.
This silicone paci is attached to a soft, cute soft toy of your choosing, and the best thing is that it’s detachable. This makes it very easy to keep clean, and even when the plush animal is still drying, you can give the binky back to your little one.
As your baby grows, you’re not obliged to change the whole thing. Nookums has made it possible to attach most other brands of pacifiers as well as its own Chillies Teether. This means that the Paci-Plushies are perfectly reusable, which is great when you’re concerned about sustainability.
A minus can be that the attached plush makes the pacifier too heavy for your baby. If that’s the case, you can still detach the stuffed animal and give it to your little one to play with separately.
- Easy to clean.
- Reusable as child grows.
- Finding pacifier when dropped made easier with toy.
- Toy might add weight to the pacifier.
7. Chicco PhysioForma Soft Silicone One Piece Orthodontic Pacifier – Best One-Piece Pacifier
The Chicco PhysioForma offers excellent value for money with its unique orthodontic design. You’ll sleep soundly, knowing that the lateral curve will aim to support your baby’s tongue placement and open the airway to facilitate breathing. On top of that, the pacifier is also constructed with a narrow base making it easier for your little one to close their lips.
For some babies, however, all of these special features might be too much and result in more rejection. If that happens, my advice is to put the paci aside and try again after a while. Your child might learn to like it over a more extended period.
The pacifier has a large handle. The downside is that it makes it slightly heavier and easier for babies to knock them out of their mouth accidentally.
- Helps with tongue placement and airflow.
- Optimal lip closure.
- Excellent price/quality ratio.
- More rejection.
- Large handle.
8. Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Soother Pacifier – Best Natural Pacifier
Super soft and natural are the most important features of the Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature pacifier. The binky’s shape is made to resemble a real breast, and so is the orthodontic nipple. It’s made of flexible silicone, moving and stretching like a mother’s nipple also would. This familiar feeling will encourage your little one to start using this binky.
The shape of the pacifier reminds me of the top part of a baby bottle. The base of the nipple blends into a curved circle, which means it will not completely rest on your baby’s face. Around the base are multiple holes helping to improve airflow and decrease irritation.
For newborns, the pacifier is a bit on the big side, but for older infants, it’s a great fit. There are two sizes available: 0 to 6 months and 6 to 18. The hollow back and harder frame around the shield make it easy for your child to hold. Tommee Tippee even thought of creating a small hole on the back, making it possible to add a clip.
The pacifier is not made out of one solid piece so it will require some extra cleaning and will have to be replaced a bit more often. Fortunately, the package already contains four pieces.
- Super soft silicone.
- Breast-like shape.
- Easy to hold.
- Multi-pieced—will need replacing more often.
9. BIBS BPA-Free Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier – Best Classic Pacifier
The BIBS paci combines a classic look with a wide range of surprising colors. This elegant style, which BIBS has been using for over 40 years, is the binky’s biggest feature. There’s a color to match every outfit your little one has.
The round rubber nipple is non-orthodontic and can sometimes hold a bit of water inside after you’ve cleaned it. But not to worry, I’d advise you to give it a good squeeze, and you’ll most probably see the water disappear. The rubber might have a bit of a smell, but that should fade after sterilization.
As the BIBS classic pacifier has the standard style of being made out of three pieces, make sure to always check all the parts before handing it over to your baby. The manufacturer also indicates on the package to replace the pacifier every month.
- Classic style.
- A wide range of unusual colors.
- Water can pile up in the nipple.
- Nipple can have typical smell of rubber.
The Perfect Paci
My personal favorite of the best pacifiers of this year is the MAM Glow In the Dark Pacifier. It’s multi-piece but easy to sterilize and the symmetrical nipple makes it easy to use. The most significant advantage is its glow in the dark feature where it is easily found at night, which helps not to interrupt your little one’s sleep.
Every baby is, of course, unique, so yours might prefer another pacifier on the list. Just think about which aspects are the most important to you and base your choice on that. Good luck!